Sunday, April 11, 2021

CONTRARY BRIN: The war on expertise... How to fight and win...

This is a full repost of David Brin's "Standard Paste-In re Wager Terms" — his repeated challenge to right-wing opponents to escrow money and bet on specific, measurable factual claims. Brin's tone is combative. The principle underneath is serious and worth separating from the rhetoric: a willingness to put money on your factual claims, under attorney-verified terms and neutral adjudication, is the strongest available epistemic commitment device.

If you will not bet on a claim, you do not actually believe it. You are performing it. This is the test that most "fact-free" political discourse cannot survive — and that is exactly why it has been so systematically avoided.

CONTRARY BRIN: The war on expertise... And ways to navigate the m...:   == Again: How to defeat the War on All expertise == The Enlightenment Experiment absolutely depends upon training citizens - especially th...

And the details:

David Brin said...

My STANDARD PASTE-IN RE WAGER TERMS: Again, here’s my challenge of bets and wagers that reveal the utter cowardice of the fact-free MAGA rightwing, Limbaugh-dittohead blowhards. "Have your lawyer write to me confirmation that you’ve escrowed $10,000 for wagers on things like ocean acidification or party differences in fiscal responsibility (budget deficits), or rates of moral turpitude in red vs. blue states, or outcomes for capitalism. Or ratios of half-truths and lies versus verifiable assertions on Fox vs. Say CNN.

"Again, if you are so certain of the accusations and denunciations and assertions you howl, after bobble-heading with Limbaugh or Hannity or Pirro then you should WANT a manly wager over those ‘facts!” You should want to bet in order to take MY money!"

Alas, experience tells me that members of the MAGA chant-hypnosis cult have neither the guts not honesty to pay off bets that aren’t secured in advance. Hence, once the stakes are escrowed then -- and only then -- will I deem it worth my time to deal with the squirming and writhing to establish clear wager metrics and to set up a panel of retired senior military officers to adjudicate.

Till I receive that missive from a reputable attorney, the record is clear. I offer manly wagers of actual facts... like the clear fact that Ocean Acidification (OA) is just one of countless metrics proving climate change is a deadly threat to our ecosystem and to our children, but OA is something we can measure *ourselves* and has no squirm allowance since it can only have come from human carbon emissions, including methane vented illegally at the compliance of the Republican Party, thus directly threatening the lives of our descendants. BET ME ON THAT!

Or let’s bet on fiscal responsibility! On which party puts the brakes on wild government deficits vs. stomping the accelerator. Or actual measurable economic outcomes.
http://davidbrin.blogspot.com/2014/06/so-do-outcomes-matter-more-than-rhetoric.html

How about the “deep state”? I’ll bet you have ZERO credible evidence for your insults spewed at the quarter of a million skilled, professional men and women in the intel agencies, FBI and military officer corps who won the Cold War and the War on Terror. Your Limbaugh-parroted yammers assert a vast conspiracy among those heroes – who defeated Hitler, stymied Stalin, thwarted Mao and got bin Laden! But suddenly they are a dark conspiracy because they say your cult is laying down for a slightly relabeled KGB and Vlad “I loved the USSR!” Putin. BET on whether those insults (of folks who are vastly better Americans than you are) can be supported at all… even… slightly… by actual fact.

Wanna go all QAnon on us? Let’s wager over which party has a higher rate of horrific pedophile monsters in its elected political caste! I’ll pay if it’s LESS than 2:1 Republican.

Let’s randomly pick ANY TEN Trumpian lies from his registered list of 30,000, about 20% of them under some degree of "oath" or accountable by law.

Can you name ONE fact-centered profession your cults isn't waging open war against? From science, teaching, journalism, law, medicine etc to those brave protectors you insult as "deep state"? Name one! Betcha can't.

Economics? Let’s sample some fact’s I’ll assemble: The job growth (measured for non-farm payrolls) under the Reagan administration averaged 168,000 per month, versus 216,000 for Carter, 55,000 for H.W. Bush, and 239,000 for Clinton… and NEGATIVE 100,000 for trump! Measuring the number of jobs created per month is limited for longer time periods as the population grows. To address this, we can measure annual job growth percentages, comparing the beginning and ending number of jobs during their time in office to determine an annual growth rate. Jobs grew by 2.0% annually under Reagan, versus 3.1% under Carter, 0.6% under H.W. Bush, and 2.4% under Clinton and NEGATIVE 3% under Trump! Yes, that sort of thing. Or let’s compare deficits, or red vs blue state rates of entrepreneurship, STDs, domestic violence, teen pregnancy, gambling and yes … abortion. Abortion goes DOWN under Democrats, you stunning-lying fool-hypocrites!


They caper and shriek and howl and writhe and jiggle about and curse and yowl... but they never stand still and stand up to settle it like men. Because they are teeny-balled Putin-servicers. Haters of every fact-centered profession. Oh, and traitors. That too.


One of my newest and rudest wager demands: I’ll bet the number of top Republicans who are proved or plausibly accused child molesters, pedophiles or seriously harmful; pervs is at least twice that of Democrats, and more likely more than 3:1. Here’s a link to a lit that’s actually much shorter than some I’ve seen:

https://old.reddit.com/r/news/comments/da96bi/army_officer_at_maralago_accessed_russian/f1od73c/

And this list leaves out Rep Jim Jordan who has never come clean about his blatant enabling of the Ohio State pedophile ring. And Lindsey Graham seriously? Care to bet me over what we'll know about him, within a few years?
To be fair, you CAN make such a list of Democrat pervs. But it is far shorter and a large majority are about porn, not directly abusing living kids.

The hypocrisy is overwhelming. A party which used to decry gambling as sin is now co-owned by Casino moguls. A party which decried divorce seems have nothing but, in its upper ranks. A party that has NEVER been fiscally responsible still fools fools into thinking that recited incantations can substitute for the real thing. Mind you, some divorces are needful and I am not a prude about gambling... (though the casinos are all evil.) It's the HYPOCRISY of lecturing us on how immoral Blue America is, when red states (except Utah) score worse in almost every category of turpitude and malgovernance.

Oh, and it is mostly blue states backing out of the insane War on Drugs.
https://old.reddit.com/r/news/comments/da96bi/army_officer_at_maralago_accessed_russian/f1od73c/

Sunday, April 4, 2021

What technology does for politics

A short compendium of the ways humans have learned to take dominion over the earth and each other.

Allows us to cater to the basest instincts of humans.
It ain't pretty, it wasn't pretty, it won't be pretty unless we force it to be. 
Hopefully we can make it pretty in the future.

10,000 BC
Farming leads to feudalism
Invention of bread allows humans to start exponential population growth.
Domestication of plants and animals (and humans: slaves are indistinguishable from peasants.)

5000 BC
Reading, writing lead to the codification of religions for the millennia
They allow the creation of cities, taxes, mass fortifications, grand palaces, royalty.

0 AD
Religion and huge empires gang up to reign over the earth. Religions invent sin for blackmail. Empires invest in mass death and invent citizenship as a reward.

1500 AD
Printing - allowed the breakdown of the Catholic Church, the Protestants. The protestors. The Great Awakenings where anyone can publish a holy book about a new religion cheaply and efficiently. 
Capitalism is invented: the ability to exploit others and not be punished by the state.

Mass printing allows the invention of the Newspaper - mass delivery of information, does this information have to be true? Nope, no way, not even most of the time. The owners of the newspapers print what sells: Yellow journalism was invented before nation states.

Newton's laws and calculus are invented. We can now prove what's the most efficient way to do something, we just have to learn how to actually do it. Manufacturing productivity increases exponentially. We are about to enter the age of over-abundance.  

1750
Steam Engine
Power if you need it.
But it's expensive, inefficient and causes us to start to burn down the earth's forests, rape it for coal and pollute the air with its putrid outputs. In Britain and the US millions die of air pollution. However, humankind finally realizes they do have the power and that royalty, that has been negotiating its own power sharing deals (see the magna carta, for instance) is not really in charge anymore if we don't let it. US breaks away from the crown. France throws the royalty under the blade and religion out of the government. As in all new forms of government, some do better than others.

1800
Individual message delivery.
I can telegraph almost anyone in the world. Great ocean spanning cables are laid, laying waste to many species of insects, trees and animals used to manufacture them. My empire can be world-wide and I don't have to wait months for information to travel at the same rates as goods on ships. I can get the info in a few minutes.
This allows nation states to really come into their own, spanning continents, creating the final form of colonialism, where Europe enslaves the world to produce goods for Europeans at the expense of native populations.

The equations of electrical fields are now understood. With the use of calculus we now know that power can be sent from one place to anywhere else. We don't know how to do this efficiently yet, but we learn quickly.

The scientific method spreads to alchemy and it becomes chemistry. Atoms are proposed but the proof and what size they are takes many decades to determine. 

1850
Photography. At this point in time photographs don't lie. The terrible consequences of slavery and colonialism become obvious to the average person. The shift in minds is irreversible. Abolition gains world wide acceptance. Feudalism ends across Europe.

In the US, desperate to save their economy, the Slave states revolt but are crushed in a brutal civil war.
Andrew Johnson gains the reigns after Lincoln's death and tries to absolve responsibility to protect the rights of ex-slaves, he's impeached but not convicted by one (bribed) vote. 
Reconstruction end soon after and Slave states begin passing black codes that allow them to arrest and force blacks into slave labor. The federal government claims it has no responsibility to protect the rights of all humans (Dred-Scott decisions.) 

The north is horrified, but with the filibuster and the gutting of the 14th amendment, there is nothing they can do beyond starting another civil war. The south begins to rewrite history and glorify the insurrection. The Indians continue to be massacred and sent to concentration camps. The government reneges on every treaty ever signed with the existing population of the continent, stealing their land to create wealth for the white colonialists. Farmers have their final victory over hunter gatherers and indigenous populations in America.

1870
The telephone comes of age! I can now call anyone anywhere, soon to be available world wide. The telegraph cables are converted to telephone, soon to be converted back to data. Empires can now get instantaneous information from any part of their empire. Wooden ships are replace by iron ships. The countries that can't keep up soon lose their empires to the new upstarts that figure out how to build ships their enemies can't sink.

Jim Crow comes into its own. It's apparently illegal to be black in the south and use any public facility. It takes many decades before the US Supreme Court finally rules this illegal and unconstitutional. 

Darwin publishes his seminal works on evolution. Racists take this theory to heart and claim scientific backing for their heinous acts. Eugenics becomes popular to 'improve' the human race.

1890
Electricity and associated systems are invented by Edison at General Electric (GE) and Tesla at Westinghouse and spread around the world quickly. This power is much more portable (as compared to steam) and begins a quick end to farming as the main employer. Farms no longer need thousands of workers. 
Automobiles and tractors take advantage of the liquid replacement of coal (gas) and start to replace animal and human labor with machines. Millions of people become unemployed. The government doesn't know what to do about it in the US and would have collapsed except for the fiat money provided by the billionaires of the time to stop the masses from starving. 
Mass death machines (machine guns and tanks) are built.  Chemistry creates cheap explosives (dynamite) and the kill ratios per dollar continue to rise exponentially, peaking almost 100 years later with the invention of the Hydrogen bomb and ballistic delivery system which can produce hell on earth in an instant. Humankind thinks it's a good idea to produce enough bombs to turn every square inch of the earth into hell many times over. They still do.

1900 to 1920
Radio is invented. The first real mass communication media (you don't have to read, literacy rates are still preventing the newspaper's ideology from taking over the minds of everyone.) But now the leader can speak to everyone at once. This leads to the politics of simpletons (royalty is slowly replaced by the cult of personality) in many countries, i.e.; fascism and communism are new governmental theories where governments and the capitalistic companies gang up together to control the means of production. In the US we opt for a more cooperative form of  socialism (FDR) which saves our country from another revolutionary war. 

It was no accident that fascism first reared it's ugly head in the country that invented radios. (Marconi in Italy.)

Automobiles replace horses, the mechanization of farming is now complete and the first attempts at mass farming by machine help to cause the dustbowl which causes substenance farming to be unsustainable in the US, causing millions to starve and be forced off the land. This increases the death and misery of the Great Depression (electricity eliminates the majority of manual work.)
While automobiles allow the starving to migrate to cities, the airplane starts to allow the populations of countries to be moved across the world. 

The last gasp of royalty in the west is eliminated in the first world war. Nation states now become powerful enough to enslave entire populations. Fiat money is created in each nation. Some nations handle this better than others. Some nations continue to starve their lower castes for decades. The majority of nations are run by gangs headed by the military, authoritarian countries where might makes right. 

The electromagnetic theory predicts infinite energy in materials as they heat up. Since this never happens, Bohr proposes a quantum theory where there's only fixed values of energy allowed. This matches what we observe. Einstein goes further and refines gravity and proposes that not only energy but light itself comes in discrete packages. He gets the Nobel prize for using statistics to predict the size and energy of individual atoms. Charge is also found to be quantized. Electron's are individually measured for the first time. 

1920 to 1940
Women get the vote. Alcohol is banned. Men revolt. Alcohol is unbanned.

Film is invented. People can see entire histories. Film makers make what sells. Imaginary histories fomenting genocide (Gone with the Wind, Nuremburg Rallies, The Birth of a Nation) are widespread and popular. This does not calm humans down, in what was thought to be the last gasp of war, we kill tens of millions of people. Then we do it again twenty years later, but this time we kill hundreds of millions. Hundreds of thousands die in a single day in the dreaded fire storm bombings in Germany and Japan. This is still hard work. It takes mass armies and air forces to deliver mass death.

The first live television broadcasts appear. This doesn't bode well as mass hysteria can now be created on demand.

The discovery of the atom leads to the discover of the nucleus and radiation. Physicists world wide recognize that their is immense destructive power locked up in each atom that dwarfs chemical energy that has driven the human race to economic super-abundance. Basically there is no reason for anyone on the earth to starve at this point. Three percent of the population can feed the rest and the rest are now available to do whatever some madman can convince them to do. Hundreds of millions starve because of madmen, and they are almost always men.

We decide to make mass death more efficient and build Atomic bombs, to bring hell on earth with a single plane. We can now kill hundreds of thousands of people and decimate any city in a single hour. America invents Superpowers. The Russians quickly follow. France and Britain follow quickly.


The age of superabundance starts with the introduction of steam power:



And more detail on what's happened since then. Over hundreds of years a 1 % increase in productivity every year produces enormous effects. What we can measure gets optimized. We'd better be sure it's the right thing.



1940 to 1980
Television continues its toll on humans and reduces the common knowledge of humankind to myths and legends.  Science struggles to justify itself, but only more mass death and warfare are funded by most governments. The US continues its colonial march across the globe, finally giving up in Vietnam when the daily reports of death and televised mayhem disabuse us of our civilizing myth. 

Science builds the nuclear bomb and the ballistic missile to deliver it. At this point we can destroy any city on earth in one hour. Mutual Assured Destruction becomes the accepted mythos of a Superpower. Wars start to become smaller and more limited. Deaths from starvation, deaths from war and deaths from genocide continue to dwindle.

In the US Jim Crow laws are declared unconstitutional. The Civil Rights Act and Voting rights act are passed in the US.  This causes the confederate states to continue racism under whatever guise they can: from no blacks voting for over one hundred years to a higher percentage of blacks than whites voting. Whites still hold the vast majority of power. Public works are destroyed because they would have to be shared with the lower caste. There's a big push to privatize government so discrimination will be allowable. School integration begins by firing all of the black teachers and shutting down black schools.

Religion, which had been slowly decaying for centuries, makes a comeback as a way to allow discrimination and the privatization of cults of personality. Strongmen appear everywhere. 

Science makes a pitch: A Space Race to the moon! Ballistic missiles are used to place men in space and land on the moon. A computer is made to control the 100 different maneuvers needed to land successfully, since weight is paramount, electronics continue to shrink in size which also increases its performance. After spreading all the pork from the space race across the country, America soon loses interest. There's no money to be made on the moon.

Democracy starts to flood the world. After the US fucks over Iran, the Philippines and Chile, we see what horror we have created and begin to push governments into our own mode, which is more stable and depends upon negotiation and cooperation, not coercion. The world becomes a much safer place. The next to last royal empire in the world collapses under its own weight as people pretend to work and the government pretends to pay them. The last royal empire in the world figures out that a command economy doesn't work, manages to stop the killing of expertise and barely manages to institute a capitalist country only be massacring millions. 

1980 to 2010
Mass delivery and world wide supply chains become common place. America exports its efficiency to the world and continues its globalization policies. Any person in the world now has access to more information than any King ever. They also have more access to disinformation than ever. Lies can now spread at the speed of light. Truth is still limited to the scientific method and its antiquated peer review and publish or perish ethos. Science doesn't care who you are, it's all in the reproducibility. Even though scientists are humans and prejudiced, the system is not racist. Nobody knows you're a dog on the internet.

The middle class grows in Asia, but peaks in the west as oligarchs figure out how to game the system and claim all the excess productivity.

Individualized mass communication to any one, any where, any time spreads across the globe. 

Television becomes unhinged from spectrum with Cable. Once limited to a few channels over the air and regulated by government to pretend to tell the truth or at least be fair, there is now no limit on what one can pass off as the truth and the light. Ignorant people continue to fall for cults of personality, refusing to invest their emotions in sports and insisting on playing politics as a game. 

The Internet explodes from three nodes in 1969 to billions*. Misinformation and propaganda are available at a click of a button, carefully curated by artificial intelligence to increase the time humans spend looking at it, dragging vast hordes of idiots into further radicalization. What was thought to be the most efficient mode of production and delivery in the world (the sears roebuck catalog and the US postal service) are now woefully inefficient by comparison. Next day delivery of anything anywhere is now possible with one click. Real information is also available with one click as search engines leverage all the hyperlinks to determine what is popular; electronic delivery of books (where the real wisdom is held) becomes instantaneous. The limiting factor is the attention span of humans.  

2010  to 2020
Localized, stylized, personalized communications point to point. Targeted marketing is perfected. Everyone has a platform to broadcast to everyone. Social media companies don't care how they get their audiences, they don't care if it starts to tear society apart or not. They have learned how to monetize outrage and it feels good! Individual messages can be targeted to individuals that radicalize and increase their usage which leads to immense network effects magnified beyond belief. Mass shootings become common in countries with guns. Pogroms, which had been diminishing start to creep up again. Genocide is now pushed down to the individual level. And it's only going to get worse.

2020 to 2030
The social networks become personalized communicators that lure you into friendship, not only do they curate your feed, they create your posts. They know what you want more than you do. They control you to maximize the profits of corporations. Amoral corporations. Governments will be overthrown. Death and mayhem will return at unprecedented levels. Control of populations will extend far beyond persuasion as people see they will be left behind in the lower caste if they don't get the latest brain implants and genetic modifications to extend their lifetimes. The human race will enslave itself to survive. The death march to competence and expertise will drown our humanity. Unless something changes this is not going to end well.

If America can't control its politics and spend their 'defense' budget policing the world, the world is doomed. Nobody else will do it. This is one of the main reasons that immigration is critical for control. Without immigrants, its just ugly Americans. With immigration, it's the best of the world fixing their own problems. 

2030 and beyond
The human borg begins to settle the planets. 
Maybe we should have never invented bread 10,000 years ago.






Thanks for reading!
 -Dr. Mike



*On October 29, 1969, ARPAnet delivered its first message: a “node-to-node” communication from one computer to another. (The first computer was located in a research lab at UCLA and the second was at Stanford; each one was the size of a small house.) The message—“LOGIN”—was short and simple, but it crashed the fledgling ARPA network anyway: The Stanford computer only received the note’s first two letters.

The Singularity: Why the Nerd Rapture will happen.

A singularity, in physics, is a moment when the equations that describe the prior state no longer apply — a phase transition after which the universe runs on fundamentally different rules. The Big Bang was one. The invention of life was another. So were sex, consciousness, language, writing, and computation.

Each singularity increased the universe's capacity to store, transmit, and compute information. The next one will be direct brain-to-brain transfer at speeds billions of times faster than language — which eventually allows the recording and playback of consciousness itself. That is the Nerd Rapture. It is real, it is coming, and this post is about why.

Big Bang

The very first singularity we know about was the Big Bang. According to Steven Hawking [1], before the Big Bang there was no time and no space. That's a huge singularity!

What's the definition of a singularity? It's when a situation changes, when the equations that described what was happening no longer apply. Before the Big Bang, without time or space, there were no equations for physical parameters. Afterwards you could make measurements and devise equations to explain what was going on. That's a HUGE singularity. Mathematical models are now actually possible.

This singularity is also reminiscent of phase changes which are well understood in physics (two recent Nobel prizes.) It's like water to ice. The average speed of the particles of water banging up against each other show off new forces depending on the temperature. What was hidden before is now exposed. The equations that describe how ice works are much, much different than the equations that describe how liquid water works. Physicists actually understand this pretty well. They can figure out how these phase changes work with some very simple parameters, and they're all the same. I don't understand the theory well enough to see if we can apply these laws to social singularities, I suspect you can, but since we barely have laws of economics that we can apply to the current situation (will inflation go up if we increase deficit spending?) we certainly can't predict this from modeling well enough to believe it. And since the objects of these predictions are affected by the predictions themselves, well, it's singularities inside singularities - feedback loops lead to chaotic results... but even chaotic results have predictable outcomes.

Opacity to Light

What are the main singularities that have occurred in this universe beyond the Big bang? There were probably many phase changes as the Big Bang settled down from infinite density to the current density of one particle per cubic meter, but the best known one is the one we can see: the Cosmic microwave background radiation. This happened when the temperature of the universe became cool enough for atoms to form and it was suddenly transparent to radiation. The radiation that existed at that moment is what we see. Before this cooling, the universe was opaque to radiation, light traveled very short distances before being scattered. After the cooling, light just continued on whichever way it was headed before, across the universe without end. That's a big change. The equations that worked before no longer worked afterward.

Life

What other singularities have we seen in the universe? I would make the claim that the next most obvious singularity was the invention of life. What is life? It's a self-sustaining physical feedback system. Life takes in energy to sustain itself which naturally leads to growth. Once life starts it either ends tragically (well, eventually always ends tragically) or continues to evolve. That's a singularity. The equations that describe the universe before life don't really hold after life evolves. Think of the Gaia hypothesis. The earth has sustained itself through many, many changes of the type of life that lives upon it. It's self-regulating, as long as it's here, now, it's obviously self-regulated itself for hundreds of millions of years. It's obvious this isn't always the case, look at Mars and Venus. Life didn't seem to make it in either of those places, so this phase change singularity stuff isn't inevitable. The new equations can lead to different solutions of death and destruction, they don't have to lead to more complicated and self-aware entities.

Sex

What's next? Maybe sex. Eukaryotic cells were made up of the combination of different entities parasitizing each other. They traded genes the hard way! By growing together into one being. This really changed the rate of evolution on the earth. Once we had gene exchange any changes that were more likely to survive had a greater chance to spread. You should read Lynn Margulis's [2] and Dorion Sagan's "Acquiring Genomes" (2003) which is a fascinating book that talks about life before animal and plant species and how cells acquired new genes (the very first type of sex.) The invention of plants and animals, where each generation is forced to trade genes increased the rate of evolution by leaps and bounds. Another singularity. The equations that worked before no longer worked.

Consciousness

What do these singularities all have in common? They increase the complexity, transmission speed and amount of storage of information. None of this was possible before the Big Bang. Then, when the universe became transparent to light, information was not limited to the small ball of plasma slowly expanding (well really fast, but not as fast as afterwards), information was expanding at the speed of light. But there was no memory and no complexity until life occurred. Evolution has continued to ratchet up the complexity, size and transmission speed of information ever since. Arguably, the next singularity is the invention of consciousness. That's when a living thing could actually have free will (and don't believe the physicists who diss free will, they're just naïve.) 

For why the determinist case is wrong, see Religion Without Lies: Why We Have Free Will (2025): the free will problem dissolves once you properly formulate consciousness as a self-modifying system.)

Life could have a complicated affect on its environment now. When life could be self modifying and learn from its mistakes, remember what happened, build models of what might happen, plan and undertake changes: That's one of the biggest singularities ever. and it was a slowly increasing evolution of complexity for this singularity until consciousness emerges.

Communication

What's next? Communication between living entities. [8] Not just eating each other, but cooperating to eat each other. Increasing the speed and breadth of information transmission again. Creating copies of 'brain' states in your fellow animals through language (body language as well as sound.) Once a group of animals or plants can work together, the equations that described life just get way, way more complicated. Domestication of plants and animals (not just by humans, by the way) was now possible. Evolution could now be directed. Think dogs, corn, cows and chickens.

Literacy

The next singularity is really the expansion of information storage outside of biological minds: reading and writing. This shows us that singularities are anything but simultaneous. It's taken almost ten thousand years for the vast majority of humans to learn to read and write.  (By the way, ngish dug 𒍑 𒅗 is Sumerian for 'to make love' [3]. I'm looking forward to my new embroidered WTF t-shirt!) Once humans learned to record things outside their brains, stuff like the pyramids and Stonehenge were now possible. City states came about and thrived. The invention of the Nation state becomes possible. The equations that described the world before writing and after writing are totally different. 

Computation

The next singularity is the ability to take that written information and to have it automatically act in and of itself. Essentially to create life again, artificial life, 'living' machines. The pyramids required humans to interpret the written instructions to build them. But soon we figured out how to build automatons, machines that ran themselves. Arguably, the first programmable computer was Babbage's Analytical Engine [4] and it wrote books of logarithms all by itself. Since then we've learned how to build feedback systems that act just like primitive living things, taking in information from the outside world and affecting that world (see cybernetics [5], whose first equations were used to build guns in the world wars.) We've learned how to perfect these little monsters and abstract their knowledge in many useful ways. This is what Artificial Intelligence (AI) does. We've learned how to reason (programming) and we've learned how to create systems that learn. This has really changed the equations that we use to describe our most complicated systems.

Communication of Consciousness

What's next? Super-smart AI that takes over the world? Hardly. See my blog post on why this is at least a hundred years away.[6] It is a singularity we're in the middle of, but the slow motion disaster/rapture will happen at glacial speed. That's not the next thing to happen. Yes, we'll be able to talk to machines in the next decade and they'll be able to understand us and we them. They'll slowly get smarter and smarter. But the real next singularity is the ability to transmit brain states between humans and machines and humans and humans billions of times faster than simple language. Direct mind to mind transmission. ESP for real. [7] Changing the speed of interaction by orders of magnitude changes those equations again.

Nerd Rapture

Once you can transmit that data at high speeds, you can start recording it. Once you can start recording it you can play it back. This will naturally evolve into the ability to record one's soul into solid state. This is a singularity because the physical receptacle can now evolve at the speed of information, doubling and doubling again, allowing larger and larger groups to cooperate at light speed. Will we ever learn how to put the soul back in the body? We'll certainly try. Will we ever learn to have the soul live outside the body? Again, we will certainly try and I wouldn't bet against it. This is the Nerd Rapture. It won't happen instantaneously, but it will happen.

Concrete steppingstones for the Nerd Rapture section:

2021–2025: Neuralink demos, Synchron FDA clearances, CTRL-labs / Meta neural interfaces

2025–2035: High-bandwidth motor and sensory interfaces; early proto-telepathy experiments

2035–2050: Whole-brain partial emulation; subjective state recording and playback

2050+: Full consciousness transfer; soul-in-solid-state

That is if the Killer Alien Robots don't get us first. It's a race of life against life. I hope we win.

Thanks for reading!

 -Dr.Mike


For the 2025 update on how the AGI timeline has shifted since this 2021 post — and why the basic framework still holds — see: An Engineer's Failed Journey to Find Artificial General Intelligence (2025).

For the 2018 development of the consciousness/singularity thesis, see: Proclamations of the Final Great Awakening (2018).


F O O T N O T E S

[1] https://www.universetoday.com/139167/heres-stephen-hawkings-final-theory-about-the-big-bang/

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynn_Margulis and https://archive.org/details/acquiringgenomes0000marg

[3] https://sumerianlanguage.tumblr.com/post/175618372191/are-there-any-known-profanity-words-in-sumerian

[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Babbage

[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cybernetics

[6] https://www.wiigf.com/2025/11/an-engineers-journey-to-detect-any-hint.html makes the argument that if the scaling laws continue for a few more orders of magnitude, it may happen earlier.

[7] To those who don't believe in ESP Extra-Sensory Perception... my remote car key says differently. I perceive the key, click it and start the care remotely. Could there be anything finer in the history of science?

[8] Arguably this is where evolution created religion as a method to evolve faster than sex allowed.

Saturday, December 26, 2020

The Power of Trump

Trumpism is not a policy program; it is a bargain. A plurality of voters, afraid of losing special status they have enjoyed for four centuries, hires the loudest available conman to protect their right to discriminate, pollute, and refuse collective obligation — accepting that they too will be conned, so long as someone else is conned worse.

What follows is an account of how the Declaration of Independence's promise of unalienable rights has been hollowed out by shrink-wrap contracts, a Voting Rights Act gutted by the Supreme Court, and the quiet constitutional triumph of the limited-liability corporation as a fourth source of power beside religion, royalty, and land. The fix is either demographic patience or a new constitutional convention. Neither is safe.

It would not be unreasonable to suppose these generalizations do violence to individual voters; they are intended to describe the center of gravity of each coalition, not its full population.

Sunday, September 6, 2020

A Modest Proposal for the Presidential Library of Donald J. Trump.

 I was reading the latest fiascos of Donald J. Trump and his aversion to showing reverence to the troops at cemeteries...when it gave me an idea that I think all red-blooded Americans can get behind and support.

To set the stage, we need to go back in history and see how other presidential estates have been turned into libraries, or cemeteries. In particular, it's educational to learn about what happened to Robert E. Lee's  estate in Arlington, Virginia. He inherited this estate from George Washington's adopted grandson. After the civil war, the United States seized the land for non-payment of back taxes (they didn't pay their property tax during the civil war...) then they turned Lee's front porch into a war memorial and a military cemetery. And they wouldn't pardon him, either. Lee went to his deathbed still a fervent white supremacists to the ends of his days. And we rewarded him by taking away his land and turning it into a cemetery to honor those he had helped to slaughter during the recent civil war. 

It seems like Donald J. Trump deserves better. We need some place to house all his tweets, television snafus, conspiracy theories, thrashing of international agreements and dog whistles of racism in one place so they can be evident for all to see. Since he doesn't read, he has no use for a library, but the American people do. We need to never forget what a kleptocratic con-man can do to this country. 

Trump is always looking for what's in it for him... so we could make a deal. Trump could donate Mar-a-lago back to the government (you probably didn't know it was a historical park for many years - and a possible Florida Whitehouse back in the 70's, but the park service thought it was too costly to maintain and the Secret Service thought it was too costly to defend) and in exchange the American people would promise not to lynch him and to build his library there.

Mar-a-lago would be a spectacular place for Trump's Presidential Library! There is no more appropriate place than Florida. We could let him stay there for as long as he likes and in return America would promise to not prosecute him for the many election fraud felonies, corruption scandals, emoluments violations and abuses of power that he has committed. He'd take that deal in a minute, he is, after all the King of the Deal! 


Maralago, on the Florida coast in Palm Beach. Two golf courses are just west of the club across the Lagoon and cover a few hundred acres. 


As it's a library and museum there's no need for a set of golf courses, instead, I propose that we turn the golf courses into the equivalent of Arlington Cemetery. We allow anyone who's died from COVID-19 to be allowed to be interned there. It's big enough we could fit every one of the probable 500,000 people he's going to end up killing because of his incompetence. If there was space left over, it could be a national debtor's graveyard, for all of those forced to go bankrupt to save their lives because of outrageous health care costs at any point because the insurance system in this country has been sabotaged by the Republican party for decades; it's only fitting to allow the dead to be memorialized there.



After the seizure the Club becomes the Donald J. Trump Presidential Library and the Golf courses become the COVID-19 Memorial Cemetery.

Does anyone think it's worthwhile setting up a non-profit organization with a fund-me to promote this idea? I think it is more than appropriate.

Thanks for reading!
 -DrMike
 6th of September, 2020, ~60 days before the coming Presidential election.


Sunday, July 5, 2020

What's Wrong With California? Utter Failure in Handling COVID-19 Pandemic in the US


China eradicated the virus in 90 days and it's economy is up and running again.

South Korea, Taiwan, Australia, Japan, New Zealand and many other countries have eliminated the virus and restarted their economies. 

Europe's death rate and case rate is continuing to go towards zero and it's economy has started to reopen.

This is not the case in United States? 
What is wrong with the United States?
Is it the same thing that was wrong with Kansas? [6]

Even worse: what's wrong with California?
Is it really too many Covidiots?
Methinks the data speaks for itself.
And the data says yes.

COVID-19 Cases and Deaths in California [5]

Since we ignored the obvious testing issues that would have allowed us to track, trace and isolate the virus into submission, we had to wait for a vaccine to have a hope of fixing it.

Cases: Note July is the first peak, when this was written. Boy did Trump Fuck it up BIGLY.



Deaths: And here's the deaths, Wow, did we screw this up big time. Everything after July was eminently preventable except for the Covidiots in the county.



California thought it was doing all the right things. We had a plan. It was all going to be over before the leaves turned orange. We were going to open up very slowly and carefully... but we never got the deaths low enough, or the cases low enough to ensure that the virus would be eradicated, so it isn't. The crazy thing about this is that we know what we have to do to eradicate this virus. It's not a secret. We've seen many countries figure it out. A hard lockdown that drives the virus to ground in three weeks. How hard could that be? Apparently too hard for a country led by a RealityTV producer; but not too hard for a country led by a former comedian: [7]

Cases of COVID-19 in Belarus


Cases per day in Chile, UK, Pakistan, Qatar and Belarus [3]

Somehow all of these countries have managed to send their cases nearly to zero by just locking down.  Something we seem unable to do in the US, except for the NYC area. So what have they done differently? Well in NYC about 15% of the population had it. This means that herd immunity would kicks when 1 - 1/Rt = 0.15 or Rt (the retransmission rate) is about 1.17. So with masks and physical distancing it appears that as long as NYC can keep Rt below 1.17, the virus will die out. And how do you keep the retransmission rate down? You test, track and isolate. 

New York State COVID-19 cases and deaths [4]

Testing tells you who has the disease. Tracking tells you who might have the disease. Isolation is the way to make sure nobody else gets the disease from those who are possibly infected. Every time you increase the interactions between people (open up the economy) or increase the probability of someone spreading the disease (don't wear a mask) you change Rt = N * Pn where N is the number of interactions and Pn is the probability of a particular interaction spreading the disease. This is why healthcare workers are infected at three times the rate of the general population; even though they are very careful and Pn is very small, they are around infected people all the time, so N is very large. Compared to a quarantined person a Nurse might have 25 times as many interactions with an infected person each day. In order to stop the rapid inundation of the hospital work force with the virus they have to reduce Pn by a factor of 25 just to stay even with the population at large.

But all of this is moot. China has shown us how to contain the virus: Test, track, isolate. They've done it three times. The original outbreak in Wuhan, a subsequent outbreak in Wuhan, and a small outbreak in Beijing. So has South Korea. Test everyone in the infected area and isolate those who are actually infected. China defined the infected area as the entire city of Wuhan at one point and performed eleven million tests in ten days to determine exactly who had the virus (about 150 people), isolated them and eliminated the retransmission to almost zero. The virus slowly dies out at this point. Reinfections from travelers can still occur, there is some small false negative rate of the testing procedures that will let infected people through, but with more testing, it can be limited to a rare event.

So we could do this in the United States. In fact, we could do it today with the right national coordination, with the current amount of testing, if we just did it right. Universities with large medical centers are doing it. Everyone at the University takes the tests to show that they are virus free before classes start, then you retake the test periodically to detect any transmissions. You track and isolate anyone who gets it so it doesn't spread. So for a University that can make it's own tests this seems like a viable proposition. 

For the United States, this isn't quite as straightforward. We don't have enough tests and we aren't increasing the number of tests fast enough.

Tests per day in US [1]

And here's how badly the previous guy failed at implementing testing: We had one more doubling of the testing rate and then he said, "Don't test, that just means we'll find more infections" What an a$$hole and fundamental Covidiot. My prediction: this is far from being over. Evolution of new variants world wide will require us to test to succeed. We should be continuing to develop instantaneous testing, if we don't we will fail again.




There doesn't appear to be any exponential growth in testing. We've only tested about 5-6 million people and we're adding new tests at the rate of 50,000 per week. For us to get enough tests to test everyone once it would take us many years, so let's hope our test creation doesn't stay linear, but actually starts to go more exponential. If we double the number of tests every month, we could test everyone in the US in another ten months. 

Another way to test everyone is to do batch testing. Since we know the average infection rate from our previous tests, we can test a bunch of people at once, with the same test, that will test positive if any of them do. To maximize the efficiency of the testing you want to make the number of samples in a test be as shown in the figure below where p is the probability of finding an infected person in the population at large. This probability can be estimated as k * Nt * Pr / PA, where Nt is the number of tests we run today, Pr is the rate of positive results, k is a factor for the missed people that are actually infected (estimated to be around 2 - 3 in the current state of affairs) and PA is the population of America.  Right now (July 4th) Nt = 700 k, Pr = 7.5 % and Pa = 350 million. So p is about k * 700 k * 7.5 % / 350 million or 1 out of 2000 people should test positive (p ~ 0.0005).

Pool Size for an expected positive test outcome percentage [2]

This says that if we tested the whole country we could do it with about 50 to 100 times fewer tests than testing everybody once. 350 million divided by 50 is 7 million tests. That's only ten times more tests per day than we do right now. If we could grow our test rate by a factor of ten and keep the virus curve flattened out (we're having a bit of trouble with this) we could then test everyone and isolate all the infected for two weeks to eradicate the virus. We should still work on a vaccine, but we should be spending almost any amount we can to increase the testing rate. The economy is losing $40 Billion per week. If each test cost $100 this would cost us less than $1B. We should be ready to do this multiple times, the pay back is huge, the uncertainty of this working is less than making a vaccine for a retrovirus (never been down before) or a corona family virus (never been done before) or bringing the vaccine to market safely in less than two years (never been done before.) 

Why isn't the federal government doing this? I have my opinions... And most of them say the failure in the current administration is driven from the top. When the conservative, republican ideology is to only do that which the leader proclaims to be a good idea and the leader doesn't understand science but only understands RealityTV production... well, we're screwed. Since this is more complicated than ratings or polls it must be baffling to the current holder of the highest office in the land. However, as soon as he is voted out in November, we can put this plan in place and be virus free by Christmas time. 

I'm feeling more optimistic than I was yesterday.

Have a merry Xmas!
Thanks for reading,
 -Dr.Mike


References:
[1] US test rate including positive test rate: https://coronavirus.jhu.edu/testing/individual-states
[3] Decreasing COVID-19 cases internationally: 
[4] Decreasing COVID-19 cases and deaths in NYC: 
[5] Increasing case rates in CA and decreasing death rates: 
[6] Believing things that are demonstrably untrue because a billionaire told you about it.
[7] I've always maintained that comedians are smarter than either actors or producers. They write their own material for at least part of their career, at least in the United States. 



Wednesday, April 29, 2020

Quantum Mechanics is weirder than you think. It might be weirder than anyone can think.

Reflections on "Experimental rejection of observer-independence in the quantum world" and an updated version "Experimental test of local observer-independence".

Are we quantum mechanical or not?

This paper basically proves that the famous Schrodinger's cat experiment, which says the cat is a quantum mechanical wave function is correct. The cat is actually in an entangled state which means the cat is alive and dead at the same time. That's pretty weird! But we an make it even weirder! Imagine, if you will, [1] that you are taking the place of Schrodinger's cat. We don't want to kill you so we'll modify the experiment in line with Deutsch's proposal and Wigner's interpretation. [2] The experiment performed above is exactly Deutsch's proposal and the result is that yes, you as the observer are in a superposition of quantum states.

What is you in that previous statement? You only ever remember one set of events. You never have any memory of being in two quantum states. It appears that consciousness can only be associated with one quantum state at a time. However it also appears that your consciousness is associated with every quantum state, viz., your consciousness splits into two versions, one associated with each quantum state. What happens to the various yous? There are two basic interpretations that are famous in quantum mechanics: the copenhagen interpretation and the multi-universe theory.

The Copenhagen interpretation says that when a measurement is made the entangled quantum state collapses. In other words, one of the quantum states disappears and the quantum system 'collapses' to the other state. Any measurement you make now will show the quantum system is in the second state. the other state is gone. If you don't make the measurement the entangled state continues to evolve and you can prove that it is still there by, for instance, making another measurement later. [3] There has never been any indication that this interpretation is 'wrong' in the eyes of the experimenter who makes the measurement. In any experimenter's view of the universe, this is exactly what happens.

Yes and No. We are not quantum mechanical in our own eyes, but we are in the eyes of others.

However, if you are taking the place of Schrodinger's cat, then to me, an observer outside the box,  you are in a quantum mechanical superposition of two different quantum states. We can actually prove this. In my eyes you are in a quantum mechanical superposition. In your eyes you are not. So what the heck is going on?

If I understand it correctly, it says that the universe looks different depending on who's looking at it. Now that's really weird, but not quite as weird as you might think. Relativity destroyed the idea that everything looks the same. Depending on how fast you are moving, the order of things happening that you observe compared to someone else can change. Events that are causal won't change, but the order of events that are not causally linked don't necessarily stay in the same order. Whew! That means that causality is not violated. Thank God and Einstein for that.

So the fundamental assumptions that are made in science are the following: locality and free choice. Locality means that two quantum mechanical wave functions can only influence each other when they are in the same place. There is no action at a distance. [4]  Free choice is that assumption that humans have free will. They can decide whether or not to make a measurement and the universe can't know ahead of time what that decision will be. [5] Or we aren't really running an experiment and it's all predetermined ahead of time.

The paper above is interesting in a couple of ways. First, it carefully defines a measurement as something done by an observer. A measurement means that an observer "extract[s] information from another system by means of some interactions, and store[s] that information in a physical memory." So even if the measurement is made, if it is not communicated to the outside world the quantum states stay in superpositions as far as the outside observer is concerned. Communicate the measurement value (not that a measurement has been made, but what measurement is made) and the superposition is broken. This seems to break the Copenhagen's interpretation of quantum mechanics... The wave function didn't collapse when the measurement is made. The wave function appeared to collapse for the observer in the box, they could predict future measurements that were dependent on the value of the measurement that occurred; but the wave function did not collapse for the observer outside the box. Their measurements were consistent with not having the wave functions collapse in the box. So who is right?

Everybody is right. The person in the box definitely made a measurement. The person outside does not know the results of that measurement, so they don't see the 'collapse'. Either the wave function somehow knows who/what is making a measurement on it when or... The many world's interpretation is correct. We are all quantum states, but consciousness splits and travels down only one path at a time. And you can never get back to the other path.

*Sigh* Yes, Quantum Mechanics is very weird.
Thanks for reading,
 -DrMike

---------------------------------------------------------

[1] Yes, this is from the Twilight Zone, and it's not a mistake or a pun, it's a possible plot that happens in the real world that is so frigging weird, it must be just from a television show. That it's what scientists think happens in REAL LIFE is the scary part.

[2] D. Deutsch, Quantum theory as a universal physical theory, Int. J. Th. Phys. 24, I (1985).
 E. P. Wigner, Remarks on the mind-body question, in: I. J. Good, “The Scientist Speculates” (London, Heinemann, 1961) and heavily using "On the quantum measurement problem", Caslav Brukner.

[3] This 'collapse' takes place instantaneously across the universe for all objects entangled together. This would seem to violate Einsteins laws of relativity that say no information can be transmitted faster than the speed of light. It turns out that it doesn't, if you assume the no-cloning-without destroying postulate, which, as far as we can tell is the way the universe works. The no-cloning postulate was proposed as a way to fix this paradox in 1982. It turns out that is was actually proved earlier in 1970 to show that any quantum measurement disturbs the quantum system.

[4] Side bar on gravity. Newton's theory of gravity assumes that the gravitational forces felt by two bodies was instantaneous and independent of distance: spooky action at a distance as Newton put it. He knew something was wrong with this theory. It turns out he was right, it's just a very good approximation to assume that the force is instantaneously transmitted between the two bodies. Einstein fixed this with his General Theory of Relativity. The forces (actually the warping of the field of space) travel at the speed of light. In most situations, it turns out that this looks like spooky action at a distance. Only in certain extreme conditions (like the orbit of Mercury, which is deep inside the grvity well of the sun) can you actually notice the difference between the two theories. And as Newton suspected, Einstein is correct and his theory is just an approximation of what we can measure. A very good approximation. So far as we can tell, Einstein's theory is exact. Although there are some 'paradoxes' when we try to reconcile it with Quantum Mechanics that hint it might not be complete and that there might be another "Theory of Everything" that would reduce to Einstein's theory in most cases, but explain away these paradoxes in the extreme cases.

[5] All those philosophers (and physicists) who claim free will doesn't exist need to reconcile their views with this postulate of science. The postulate of free choice says that there does not exist a deterministic universe. It says that the experimenter can choose which measurement to make and nothing that has gone on before can determine which choice the experimenter will make. Of course, if everything is determined ahead of time... then we are just in a simulation and our free will is an illusion. However, free will is an open postulate, you can assume we have it or not. Science works both ways. In one case, the measurements we make are predetermined, in the other case the measurement results are random. In the latter case we have free will. In the former case we don't. In the latter case some predetermined 'hidden variables' are causing the measurements to look random. The philosophy of Occam's razor leads me to believe in the former: Human's have free will and measurements can be made via free choice and their results are randomly distributed. Of course, if you think everything is predetermined and we are living in a simulation, why would this simulation be running? What is being simulated? It could only be different initial conditions. And why would anyone want to simulate that? Or we aren't in a simulation and everything is predetermined. There is absolutely no fun in that. No fun at all. I reject that position on the postulate that humans can have fun.









The American Dream

We aren't losing it, it's being ripped from our hands by America's techno-Lords. They are the most unempathetic, corrupt and rac...