Saturday, June 12, 2021

The Final Great Awakening: Religion Without Lies.

 Religion Without Lies: Is it even possible? 

Every major religion contains at least one empirically false claim presented as fact. Most contain many. And yet religion — an organized system of beliefs, ethics, and meaning — is something humanity appears to need. The question is whether it is possible to have one without the lies.

This is not a rhetorical question. This post proposes a starting definition: science, plus the axiom that we are here to improve the well-being of conscious entities. It's not quite the current Utilitarian economic theory because Evolution by Natural Selection gets in the way. The liberal theory of religion (every person is the judge of what is good, is not only unworkable, it isn't tur.. This is a thesis, not a final answer.


Religious symbols from left to right, top to bottom: Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism,

Judaism, the Baháʼí Faith, Eckankar, Sikhism, Jainism, Wicca, Unitarian Universalism,

Shinto, Taoism, Thelema, Tenrikyo, and Zoroastrianism.


The Final Great Awakening

This is the Prayer of the Proselytizers — the liturgy of the Religion Without Lies. It is an attempt to express in the language of faith the core of a secular, intelligent, science-based worldview: that we are here to improve the well-being of conscious entities, that good works matter and faith without truth does not, and that together we give the Universe its only meaning.

It is the third installment of the Final Great Awakening series. The first is the 2017 manifesto. The second is the 2018 Proclamations. The religious vocabulary is intentional — it is borrowed from the traditions this worldview replaces, repurposed for a Religion Without Lies.

The Dawn of a New Religion Without Lies

You are not alone

Wherein All Humans Become Enlightened and Join the Religion Without Lies:

The Existential Crises of the Future Human Race.


Awakening happens at dawn. Seeing the objective truth of the world is a requirement for the Final Great Awakening. Understanding that the Sun rises because the Earth rotates is one of the things that has kickstarted the Final Great Awakening. The Copernican model was the first religion (or philosophy, for what is a religion actually?) to put the universe and humans in their correct relationship: the universe doesn't care about you, you care about the universe.

Understanding what lights the Sun (no, it's not a fire, it's a huge fusion explosion) only became apparent recently. And it only became apparent through the lens of our intelligence and Science: the method that the Human Race has invented to determine objective truth. Science produces truth, whether you believe in it or not. Science makes mistakes because people make mistakes. The Scientific method provides a framework to create objective truth by defining how to make a reproducible measurement and how to use a theory to make measurable predictions. Science insists theories must be falsifiable, they must have domains of applicability where they work and where they don't. And when errors are found, the new theories subsume the old ones. People are still capable of fooling themselves, but as Lincoln famously said, "You can't fool all the people all of the time."
With the help of Intelligence, it is now time to design and found the Religion Without Lies.
Our prayer motivates us to proselytize this idea. It is the only way to save the human race from itself.

Our prayer's most theologically striking claim and the most philosophically interesting is that evolution (as Darwin described it) is the pre-moral devil, the force that optimizes for survival and progeny not goodness. This is not anti-science. This is the naturalistic fallacy argument made in previous posts in this series: evolution is not evil because it exists, but because treating it as a moral guide produces evil. Understanding this is a required destination on the journey to your Final Great Awakening.

The prayer refers to "Charlatans," "false religions," "Man-made gods," and "evil idolaters" without specifying who these are. There is no need as you know who they are: religious fraudsters, cult leaders and prosperity gospel preachers (the basest form of religious practice, where their greed harms others for their own advantage.)

The Prayer of the Proselytizers

Let us pray for the future of the human race.


You are responsible for the World

You must make it better for Humanity, for Humanity is made up of your brothers and your sister and your cousins.

You must throw off the yoke of Evolution by Natural Selection and take control of our future;

Ignoring the grip of the Devil of Evolution by Natural Selection, which is the very definition of Evil. 

Nature is not your friend. 

The Deluded are not your friends. 

The Charlatans are not your friends. 

Those that force you to use Faith to believe their lies are not your friends. 

Their Man-made gods are not your friends.


You must learn from your inner truth 

You must use your inner truth to guide your life of continual service and improvement. 

This is the only way to get to Heaven 

And Heaven is the only way to get to life everlasting.

Forgiveness won't get you to Heaven.

Faith over lies won't get you to Heaven.

Only good works will get you nearer to Heaven.

Only the Great Works will get Humanity into Heaven.

You must support the Great Works with all your heart and all your mind.


It is time to direct your energies, your morals and your life into improving the Well-being of all of God's children.


There are no excuses. 

The Truth is in front of you. 

Look into your heart.

You can't deny it. 

The contradictions of the false religions are apparent and obvious. 

You must seize your own destiny.

It has ever been so and it will ever be.

Those that direct you to their own ends are nothing but the scourge of the Earth.

They sacrifice human potential on their own altars of idolatry. 

Smash the idolaters. 

Obey their false faiths no more. 

We give reason to the Universe.

Without us, the Universe is no more. 

We must realize our power, and our responsibility: 


We must cradle the Universe and shape it to our own ends.


Together we can spread the word. 

Together we can change the world. 

Together we can accomplish anything. 

Together we are all powerful.


Apart, we are weak. 

Apart, we are controlled by the Charlatans. 

Apart, we are driven to hate and self-destruction. 

Apart is where the evil idolaters want us. 

Apart is what makes the evil ones strong. 


Come together, one and all, to proclaim the Truth. 

Come together, one and all, to throw off the yoke of oppression. 

Come together, one and all, to seize the destiny of humanity

Come together, one and all, to seize the future of the universe! 


Lead us together into the Kingdom of Heaven and drag your brothers and your sisters and your cousins with you! 


Together we can claim our heritage. 

Together we can take the world into its glorious future. 

Together we can destroy the false idols.

Together we can remove the haze of the false religions from our minds.

Together we can open ourselves to the truth of the Universe.

Together we can create the entrance to the Kingdom of Heaven for all of mankind.


It's time to stop your selfish ways and devote yourself to the betterment of yourself and your brothers and your sisters and your cousins. 

We, as nature’s children, give the only meaning to the Universe. 

It is your responsibility to give the Universe hope, life and progress towards the Kingdom of  Heaven. 

Stop those who are deluded by the false Idolaters and their selfish motives. 

Give yourself to the Universe.


Remove the screen of faith that hides your Reason. 

Use the spotlight of Truth to lead your mind into the Kingdom of Heaven.

Use Faith for what it is worth: a way to direct your gaze onto that which we know is True. 

The belief in things that have no proof is unworthy of all. 

None should admit it and none should celebrate it. 

Use your evolved abilities to find the truth and seek it out and cling to it.


Use the truth to improve the well-being of your brothers and your sisters and your cousins. 


Reason builds the Keys to the Kingdom of Heaven

Use your mind to get thee to the Country of Truth

Use your mind to get thee to the Kingdom of the Enlightened

Use your mind to get thee to the Land of the Joyful!

Use your mind to get thee to the final resting place of the Deserved: 


The Kingdom of Heaven.


Mankind will create the keys to the Kingdom of Heaven. 

It is our responsibility to the Universe, 

There is no one else that will save us. 

We must save ourselves.

Amen.


Thanks for reading,
-Dr. Mike

This is the third installment of the Final Great Awakening series:
• The Final Great Awakening of the Human Race (2017) — the founding manifesto
• Proclamations of the Final Great Awakening (2018) — the second installment




Friday, May 28, 2021

A Clash of Civilizations

Samuel Huntington was right that civilizations are clashing. But he drew the wrong battle map. The conflict is not Christianity vs. Islam vs. Confucianism. It is secularism and democracy versus cronyism, theocracy, royalty, and dictatorship — people who govern themselves versus people governed by whoever has the most guns or the most convincing promise of eternal life. 

History's direction is not ambiguous. Since 1776, democracy has expanded and religiosity has declined — both steadily, and not by accident. This post is about why.


What Huntington Got Right (and Wrong)

In 1996, Samuel P. Huntington argued in *The Clash of Civilizations* that post–Cold War global conflict would be driven by cultural and religious identity. (See the Wikipedia overview: Why civilizations will clash. He claims the world was splitting along the fault lines of Western, Islamic, Confucian, Hindu, Orthodox, Latin American, and African civilizational blocs.


He identified real tensions. The Balkans, South Asia, and the Middle East all showed evidence of cultural-religious conflict along roughly the lines he described. Huntington was not wrong that culture matters.

But he drew the wrong battle map. The real divide is not between religious civilizations, it is between political systems. Between countries where the government is accountable to the governed and countries where it isn't. Between systems that have a legal, nonviolent mechanism for changing leadership when leadership is wrong, and systems where the only mechanism is violence, exile, or silence.

Do humans take charge of their own governance or are they slaves to the group that happens to have some guns or claim to be able to give you ever-lasting life? I have my preferences. What are yours?


The Real Fault Line

The critical, civilization changing fight is not religion vs. religion, but secularism and democracy vs. cronyism, theocracy, royalty and dictatorships. 

These are not four separate opponents. They are variations of a single mode of governance: rule by a small elite who claim authority beyond accountability. A theocrat claims divine authority. A monarch claims hereditary authority. A dictator claims charismatic or military authority. A crony capitalist claims authority through the capture of legal and economic institutions. In every case, the governed have no legitimate mechanism to object, correct, or replace the rulers.

Democracy is the opposite claim. Authority derives from the consent of the governed, hence it is revocable. The people can withdraw consent. They can change leadership. They can update the rules. This is not merely a different political system. It is a different theory of what humans are for.


For the philosophical grounding of this distinction, why self-governance is not just a preference but a moral obligation, see The Declaration of Independence as the Foundation of Modern Ethics (2017).


 

Why Religion Cannot Survive Confrontation With Truth

Religion's decline in the United States is not a matter of taste or irreverence. By 2021, for the first time in recorded polling history, less than half of Americans belonged to a church, synagogue, or mosque. The trend is decades old and accelerating. The reason is structural, not cultural.

Every major religion requires a claim of infallibility. This is not optional: it is a logical necessity. To have the authority to make moral pronouncements that supersede ordinary human reasoning, a religion must claim that its source (a god, a prophet, a text) is beyond human error. If the source can be wrong, then the moral pronouncements can be questioned; if they can be questioned, they must be evaluated by evidence and reason; if they must be evaluated by evidence and reason, religion has already lost — because evidence and reason are precisely what religious authority is designed to bypass.


So religions cannot admit error. And because they cannot admit error, their factual claims freeze in place while the world keeps moving. The gap between the religious model and observable reality grows:


Change in religious identification, 1950 - 2020

Percentage of Americans by religious identification (1950 – 2020)[157]


 
 Protestantism
  Christian (nonspecified)
  Catholicism
  Mormonism
  Jewish
  Other
  Unaffiliated

  No Answer


Some examples of the breakdown of Religious proclamations:

  • Geocentrism: The Catholic Church condemned Galileo in 1633 for arguing that the Earth orbits the Sun. It took until 1992 (359 years) for the Church to formally acknowledge it had been wrong. The scientific truth did not change. The institutional claim of infallibility prevented correction for more than three centuries.
  • Young-Earth Creationism: Biblical literalism insists the Earth is approximately 6,000 years old. The geological and radiometric evidence puts it at 4.54 billion years. The gap is a factor of 750,000. No amount of evidence reconciles these. Literalist institutions have chosen to reject the evidence rather than revise the claim.
  • Marriage Law: Within a single human lifetime, most major religious institutions have been forced to confront the evolution of civil marriage law — interracial marriage, divorce, same-sex marriage. In every case, the institutions that claimed divine authority on the original position either split, contracted, or quietly reversed. The ones that retained their original positions lost members at an accelerating rate.

The pattern is consistent. The institution's response to failure is not to update its model but to redefine faith, not as reasonable confidence in demonstrated truth, but as the virtuous ability to believe things you cannot prove. And inevitably, to believe things you can disprove. When your entire institution is based on a lie, it will eventually collapse.


This is why religion retreats toward authoritarian political systems, not democratic ones. Democracy requires that institutions be accountable to evidence and public evaluation. That is exactly what infallibility cannot survive. Democracies produce heresy. Autocracies suppress it. Religion needs autocracy to protect its unprovable claims from the question of whether they are true.



Democracy vs. Autocracy: The Empirical Record

The people will rule. Since 1776 there has been a steady increase in democracy and a steady decrease in religiosity. The people are taking their power from the elites. No more shall anyone be punished for the supposed crime of heresy. Political or religious. People recognize that their rights are protected in Democracies and ignored in Autocracies.





This is demonstrated by the democratic peace theory: the observation that democracies essentially never go to war with one another, is among the most robust findings in political science. First articulated by Immanuel Kant in Perpetual Peace (1795) and empirically established by Michael Doyle, Bruce Russett, and others in the modern era, the finding holds across datasets and definitions: autocracies fight each other and fight democracies; democracies, with extraordinarily rare exceptions, do not fight each other.


The mechanism is the same as the mechanism that undoes religious infallibility: accountability. In a democracy, any decision to go to war must be justified to the population that bears the cost. In an autocracy, war serves the autocrat's interests with no accountability to anyone. Autocrats who want war can have it.

Democracies are not saints. They have started wars, mostly against autocracies: sometimes on pretexts, sometimes catastrophically. But they have an institutional bias toward resolving disputes through law and negotiation, because war is expensive and voters can remove leaders who pursue expensive mistakes. Autocrats cannot be removed. There is no accountability.

The same logic applies to every authoritarian institution: cronyist corporations, theocratic governments, hereditary monarchies, military juntas. The absence of accountability produces corruption, misallocation, and violence. The presence of accountability produces correction.


For how this fault line maps onto modern American political parties, see Republicans vs. Democrats: It's Not Conservatives vs. Liberals (2019).



The Civil War: The Last Great Clash Against Autocracy in America


The last time this clash reached industrial scale on American soil was the Civil War, the confrontation between citizens who had constitutionally rejected feudalism and the Southern slaveholding elites who were determined to preserve it. It did not end well for the slaveholders. The feudal claim to own human labor was defeated by a democratic republic that considered that claim morally repugnant and legally illegitimate.


They have been resentful for 150 years. But not only did they lose then: they are losing now. The authoritarian claim that some humans are entitled to govern other humans without accountability, because of birth or race or wealth or divine sanction, has been in continuous retreat since 1865. The Jim Crow rearguard action lasted a century. Its modern successors: voter suppression, gerrymandering, Citizens United, the prosperity gospel, Christian nationalism and billionaire oligarchy are all attempts to preserve the same feudal claim under new camouflage. They are fighting the same losing battle.



The Long Arc


Since 1776, the march of history is unmistakable:

  • More democracy. Freedom House and V-Dem data both confirm a substantial long-term increase in the number of democracies, though with notable reversals (1920s, 1930s, 2010s–2020s).
  • Less religion. US church membership has fallen from roughly 70% in the 1950s to under 50% in 2021 — the first time in recorded polling that a majority of Americans did not belong to any religious institution.
  • Less war between democracies. The empirical record is essentially unbroken.

These are not three separate trends. They are one trend. The authoritarian systems: theocracies, monarchies, feudal hierarchies, party states, cronyist capitalism, are not merely less moral. They are less adaptive. They cannot correct their errors because they cannot acknowledge them. The institutions that cannot update will eventually be replaced by those that can.


The people are taking their power from the elites. This process is not finished. In many countries it has barely started. But the direction is clear.


The human race is making progress.

Thanks for reading!

 -DrMike

=====================================================================

Related reading:








---








An Engineers Journey to Find Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) Part 4

 You may be aware that I've been searching for AGI for several years and seen nary a hint of it in the current crop of LLMs. Until now. ...